I’ve been reading some information about Bush’s new Department of Health and Human Services rule and it’s seriously fucked up. In effect, it will deny funding to any medical facility that does not certify in writing that it’s employees have the right to withdraw their care, omit information and in all ways refuse to offer or assist with treatment based on their own personal objections (moral, religious, whatever).
A ruling that protects the “conscience” in very shady vague language can be taken to extremes in application.
What about protecting patients (especially women) and their right to adequate healthcare and information necessary to make choices that will impact their bodies, their health and sometimes their very lives?
Healthcare providers already have a choice to protect their conscience, it’s called “don’t choose that profession.” By all means, remove yourself from a situation where your own personal issues are infringing on a patient’s right to walk into your office and be treated with respect and dignity. You do not have the right to make choices for a patient -whether or not to give them complete information about their options, choices and care- based on your feelings. Sorry.
But if you are going to choose a career in healthcare and you show up for work, you have to do your job. That’s the way it works. Or at least, that is the way it should work by all reasonable assumptions. Those of us in America that have the privilege to be insured (I’m not one of them) pay a fuck lot of money to be able to receive healthcare and there is already a serious lack of coverage that puts the patient, not the profits first.
So the pecking order is what, now? 1. Profits (Insurance Companies) 2. Profits (Lobbyists) 3. Profits (Healthcare companies and workers) 4. The arbitrary given privilege of Healthcare workers to now bring their religious and moral objections to care into the workplace. 5. Patients? Maybe… I’m sure there are even others profiteering off of this bullshit higher up than the patients.
This is 800 different kinds of wrong. I wish I could say that I can’t believe this is happening, but really, I can… I just can’t believe that this is being allowed to happen without mega protests and media coverage. This is huge.
There is a 30-day comment period, in which the DHHS is accepting comments on this proposal before the ruling goes into effect. It is over on September 25th.
It takes less than 5 minutes - Planned Parenthood has set up a handy form to help, just fill it out and click it. PLEASE. There needs to be more of a public outcry about this.
If you want more info, here is Planned Parenthood’s Fact Sheet about the rule. And here is an op-ed that was in the NY Times, by Hillary Rodham Clinton and Cecile Richards, urging us all to take action now. Here is an excerpt:
Health and Human Services estimates that the rule, which would affect nearly 600,000 hospitals, clinics and other health care providers, would cost $44.5 million a year to administer. Astonishingly, the department does not even address the real cost to patients who might be refused access to these critical services. Women patients, who look to their health care providers as an unbiased source of medical information, might not even know they were being deprived of advice about their options or denied access to care.
….
The rule would also allow providers to refuse to participate in unspecified “other medical procedures” that contradict their religious beliefs or moral convictions. This, too, could be interpreted as a free pass to deny access to contraception.
Many circumstances unrelated to reproductive health could also fall under the umbrella of “other medical procedures.” Could physicians object to helping patients whose sexual orientation they find objectionable? Could a receptionist refuse to book an appointment for an H.I.V. test? What about an emergency room doctor who wishes to deny emergency contraception to a rape victim? Or a pharmacist who prefers not to refill a birth control prescription?
The Bush administration argues that the rule is designed to protect a provider’s conscience. But where are the protections for patients?
I know there is a lot happening right now in our country – a lot happening in the media that is scary and overwhelming (the pending election issues and financial meltdowns) – but this is just as URGENT and has consequences that will effect people’s lives almost immediately. This rule is not acceptable. I seriously can’t just allow this to happen and I hope you feel the same. Please take a few minutes to send a comment!